The Problem with Unsolicited Advice: When Helping Isn’t Helpful

Ever been on the receiving end of unsolicited advice or unwanted “help”?
You’re not alone.

While these responses often come from good intentions, the experience can leave you feeling misunderstood, unheard, more anxious, and less connected — the exact opposite of what you likely needed in that moment.

In my experience, unsolicited advice usually says more about the giver’s need to alleviate their own discomfort than it does about what the recipient actually needs. When we care about someone in pain, it’s tempting to jump into problem-solving mode — to say the right thing, offer the quick fix, or ease the suffering as fast as possible. But more often than not, what’s most healing isn’t a solution — it’s presence.

If You’re Supporting Someone in Pain

Instead of offering advice right away, try slowing down. Be attentive. Ask gentle, curious questions. Let them lead.

There is power in sitting with someone’s pain without trying to fix it. It takes patience, humility, and a willingness to be uncomfortable. But in that discomfort, something meaningful happens: the person suffering gets to be seen, heard, and accompanied — not managed.

Sometimes, just being present is the most profound form of support.

If You’re on the Receiving End

If you’ve received unsolicited advice or “help” that felt intrusive or invalidating, you’re not overreacting.

When it feels safe, consider gently naming your need:
“I really appreciate you wanting to support me. Right now, I don’t need advice — I just need someone to sit with me.”

Often, these moments can be an opportunity for deeper connection. Letting people know what’s truly helpful — and what isn’t — can expand their capacity to show up differently, more attuned and more grounded.

As a Therapist...

My hope is to be a quiet companion to my clients in their suffering — not to rush their process, not to “fix,” but to be a steady presence.

To offer a space where their pain can unfold in its own time.
To trust that their truths will emerge when they’re ready.
To hold space that invites real transformation—not through answers, but through witnessing.

Because sometimes the most powerful thing we can offer each other isn’t advice at all.
It’s presence. It’s patience. It’s the gift of not needing to do anything except be here.

Hatty J. Lee, LMFT (she/her) is an Asian American licensed marriage and family therapist and brainspotting practitioner who has been practicing for 14 years in community mental health settings, schools, and private practice virtually across California and in-person in Los Angeles and Pasadena, California. As the founder and clinical director of a group practice called Oak and Stone Therapy in Los Angeles, CA, she trains clinicians and supports people to deepen their relationship with themselves and the most important people in their lives. She writes about mental health on her Instagram and is the co-author of The Indwell Guide that integrates visual storytelling, mental health education, and practical tools to support people to heal and thrive.

Hatty J. Lee

Oak & Stone Therapy is a team of Asian American therapists who offers individual, couples, child and teens, and family therapy virtually across California and in-person in Los Angeles and Pasadena, California.

http://www.oakandstonetherapy.com
Previous
Previous

The Power of Shame — and How We Begin to Loosen Its Grip

Next
Next

To Be Seen or To Be Safe: The Cost of Hiding and the Freedom of Showing Up